Does The Hip Hop Generation Breed Horrible Quarterbacks?
September 11th, 2008 . by ChuckIf you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed to receive instant updates.
I generally avoid everything Uncle Ruckus Jason Whitlock writes, but every now and then I’ll hear about his articles from a third party source (Pro Football Talk in this case). The article is based around Vince Young’s latest troubles and his opinion that the best quarterbacks need to come from a two parent household.
“It’s not about color. It’s about fitting the profile of someone who can handle all that goes along with being an NFL quarterback. If I’m an owner, I spend my quarterback dollars on young men who were raised by strong fathers. It wouldn’t be an infallible system, but on average I bet I’d hit more winners than if I turned over the leadership of my team to a kid who isn’t used to having a strong male authority figure.”
I don’t have a HUGE problem with this statement, I wouldn’t say it’s ironclad, but it could very well be true in most cases… who knows. I did have a problem with the following however…
“The position requires thick skin and genuine self-confidence. If you need four or five male groupies with you at all times, a half million dollars of jewelry around your neck and wrists and a dozen tattoos to feel confident, then maybe you should play wide receiver or start rapping.”
100% bullshit.
Not only does it make sweeping generalizations about young black males who participate in hip hop culture, it reinforces stereotypes that black athletes aren’t smart enough to play quarterback.
Most quarterbacks that come into the league are going to fail PERIOD. You don’t hear these types of questions about failed quarterbacks like Alex Smith, Matt Leinart, and David Carr. I’m not saying these three guys didn’t face criticism, I’m saying they don’t receive the same questions that a Vince Young or Michael Vick have gotten.








1. This Brett Favre vs. Aaron Rodgers thing is going to get tired QUICK.